Detective Mafia - Search for a Clue

[Deleted]

Unfortunately I don't have any dirt on Mafia or Neutrals at the moment, hence the reason you don't see me pointing fingers.

[Deleted]

remove vote

I'm good.

[Deleted]

Hmmmm. I'm not a tracker. What do you do, Bourbon?

You don't have to be specific. You can be generic.

Who is the other person you know to be town?

[Deleted]

Bourbon is on the up and up. I had no reason for pressure other than Bourbon not being on the Vermouth lynch.

[Deleted]

Jun 23, 2015 13:11:53 GMT -6 @bourbon said:

Unfortunately I don't have any dirt on Mafia or Neutrals at the moment, hence the reason you don't see me pointing fingers.

Jun 23, 2015 13:08:32 GMT -6 @bourbon said:

Jun 23, 2015 12:18:46 GMT -6 @tequila said:

I take it you targeted me last night?

Indeed I did. I'm not too sure it would be wise to out more town to the mafia at the moment, but if people are going to continue pushing for me, I'll give the name.

These two statements appear odd to me. Why would you have dirt on someone if you were targeting Tequila last phase, who helped bust mafia? You seem to be claiming an info gatherer in the top quote that has not hit gold yet, and then you seem to be claiming something else in the bottom quote (no reason to gather info on Tequila, really).

And Tequila, what prompted you to ask whether or not Bourbon targeted you last night?

[Deleted]

I am here and I am not sure why Mead keeps insisting on pushing my way. I have been nothing if not cooperative and truthful. I gave all of my information except for my power, which I am more than willing to claim if needed.

I think we should try to figure this mafia theme out so we can put this to rest. I am both in a movie and children's books. So it Batman. So is Professor Layton. And we are all animated. Any townies fit that bill too? Is there sherlock holmes cartoon? I would like to put this ongoing deflection to rest so we can move onto actual threats.

[Deleted]

Jun 23, 2015 13:29:33 GMT -6 @rum said:

Jun 23, 2015 13:11:53 GMT -6 @bourbon said:

Unfortunately I don't have any dirt on Mafia or Neutrals at the moment, hence the reason you don't see me pointing fingers.

Jun 23, 2015 13:08:32 GMT -6 @bourbon said:

Indeed I did. I'm not too sure it would be wise to out more town to the mafia at the moment, but if people are going to continue pushing for me, I'll give the name.

These two statements appear odd to me. Why would you have dirt on someone if you were targeting Tequila last phase, who helped bust mafia? You seem to be claiming an info gatherer in the top quote that has not hit gold yet, and then you seem to be claiming something else in the bottom quote (no reason to gather info on Tequila, really).

And Tequila, what prompted you to ask whether or not Bourbon targeted you last night?

You seem to be asking an awful lot of questions. If you think that Tequila and I are in cahoots together, he voted for me first after I said that I wouldn't vote for Liquor until we heard from him. And if you believe that I was trying to defend Liquor, I will gladly vote for him after we hear from him.

As for me, I can choose any other player or I can choose any power. Whichever I choose, the other is randomized. I chose to cop both nights in a row, in which I got two random results, which were both town.

[Deleted]

Jun 23, 2015 13:34:27 GMT -6 @champagne said:

I think we should try to figure this mafia theme out so we can put this to rest. I am both in a movie and children's books. So it Batman. So is Professor Layton. And we are all animated. Any townies fit that bill too? Is there sherlock holmes cartoon? I would like to put this ongoing deflection to rest so we can move onto actual threats.

The Hardy Boys were a children's book and cartoon as well, and they were town. 
Sherlock was in an animated series. I wouldn't go so far as to classify him as "children's literature"

[Deleted]

The anonymous aspect is interesting. I've thrown out several questions over the last few days that have been ignored. I think we are all playing our cards close to the chest (except at least one who is keeping it close to the bust......).

The day phases are both quiet and intentional. I find this interesting.

[Deleted]

The scooby gang is also animated so taht is not it. And it looks like there is a sherlock holmes cartoon.

[Deleted]

..then how do you know your target was Tequila? That power makes no sense.

[Deleted]

Jun 23, 2015 13:38:36 GMT -6 @bourbon said:

Jun 23, 2015 13:29:33 GMT -6 @rum said:

These two statements appear odd to me. Why would you have dirt on someone if you were targeting Tequila last phase, who helped bust mafia? You seem to be claiming an info gatherer in the top quote that has not hit gold yet, and then you seem to be claiming something else in the bottom quote (no reason to gather info on Tequila, really).

And Tequila, what prompted you to ask whether or not Bourbon targeted you last night?

You seem to be asking an awful lot of questions. If you think that Tequila and I are in cahoots together, he voted for me first after I said that I wouldn't vote for Liquor until we heard from him. And if you believe that I was trying to defend Liquor, I will gladly vote for him after we hear from him.

As for me, I can choose any other player or I can choose any power. Whichever I choose, the other is randomized. I chose to cop both nights in a row, in which I got two random results, which were both town.

I'm not at all suspicious of Tequila. I'm just asking questions. As you already power claimed, would you mind throwing out a name as well? 

[Deleted]

There is a Sherlock Holmes cartoon. I think there are actually more than one.

[Deleted]

I am from an animated cartoon but that cartoon is in no way meant for children.

[Deleted]

So it is not simply cartoons. The neutrals all have animated movies. Do any of the other autopsied roles fit that bill?

[Deleted]

Jun 23, 2015 13:40:52 GMT -6 @mead said:

..then how do you know your target was Tequila? That power makes no sense.

Did your PM come back with something like:

"Cognac came back town?"

Sorry to keep using you as a talking point, cognac.  I love cognac.  Favorite liquor.  

[Deleted]

Jun 23, 2015 13:40:07 GMT -6 @champagne said:

The scooby gang is also animated so taht is not it. And it looks like there is a sherlock holmes cartoon.

Marple was animated as well. 

[Deleted]

I mean, I'm town, and my character has been featured in virtually every medium you can think of.

[Deleted]

Jun 23, 2015 13:45:32 GMT -6 @rum said:

Jun 23, 2015 13:40:52 GMT -6 @mead said:

..then how do you know your target was Tequila? That power makes no sense.

Did your PM come back with something like:

"Cognac came back town?"

Sorry to keep using you as a talking point, cognac.  I love cognac.  Favorite liquor.  

No worries, it's not as if you're using my name in a negative way.
Besides that I'm interested in the answer to your question myself.

[Deleted]

Jun 23, 2015 13:42:31 GMT -6 @rum said:

Jun 23, 2015 13:38:36 GMT -6 @bourbon said:

You seem to be asking an awful lot of questions. If you think that Tequila and I are in cahoots together, he voted for me first after I said that I wouldn't vote for Liquor until we heard from him. And if you believe that I was trying to defend Liquor, I will gladly vote for him after we hear from him.

As for me, I can choose any other player or I can choose any power. Whichever I choose, the other is randomized. I chose to cop both nights in a row, in which I got two random results, which were both town.

I'm not at all suspicious of Tequila. I'm just asking questions. As you already power claimed, would you mind throwing out a name as well? 

I am Inspector Gadget. A cartoon character who is awfully clumsy. My power makes perfect sense, considering the character.

[Deleted]

Jun 23, 2015 13:45:32 GMT -6 @rum said:

Jun 23, 2015 13:40:52 GMT -6 @mead said:

..then how do you know your target was Tequila? That power makes no sense.

Did your PM come back with something like:

"Cognac came back town?"

Sorry to keep using you as a talking point, cognac.  I love cognac.  Favorite liquor.  

How does it not make sense? I can choose a power to use, or I can choose another player. Whichever I do not choose specifically, the other is randomized. As I don't want to randomly kill somebody (because I could, but am not limited to just those two), I elected to investigate people both previous nights.

Yes, my message came back as "Tequila is Town".

[Deleted]

So you have used this power exactly twice, then.

It makes sense, but it required clarification.

[Deleted]

I'm satisfied with Bourbon's info for now.

remove vote

I think it's still too early to nail down a theme (says the person who dropped a theme idea day 2). We don't have much evidence, and until another mafia flips I'm afraid it's going to be pretty tough to put together any solid guesses.

[Deleted]

Man, I am not a fan of that claim at all. Easy to fake and easy to point to if you're caught accidentally killing someone.

[Deleted]

Jun 23, 2015 14:15:57 GMT -6 @mead said:

Man, I am not a fan of that claim at all. Easy to fake and easy to point to if you're caught accidentally killing someone.

There is that, but Tequila knew he was targeted and it did not seem to interfere with his targeting.

[Deleted]

Jun 23, 2015 14:25:51 GMT -6 @rum said:

Jun 23, 2015 14:15:57 GMT -6 @mead said:

Man, I am not a fan of that claim at all. Easy to fake and easy to point to if you're caught accidentally killing someone.

There is that, but Tequila knew he was targeted and it did not seem to interfere with his targeting.

I wouldn't say that.  Bourbon said he trusted Tequlia and another as Town.  I think it was a good assumption that Bourbon was claiming he copped Tequila. Of course, now it's a bit more complicated than that, but it wasn't that hard to follow.

[Deleted]

Jun 23, 2015 14:32:07 GMT -6 @mead said:

Jun 23, 2015 14:25:51 GMT -6 @rum said:

There is that, but Tequila knew he was targeted and it did not seem to interfere with his targeting.

I wouldn't say that.  Bourbon said he trusted Tequlia and another as Town.  I think it was a good assumption that Bourbon was claiming he copped Tequila. Of course, now it's a bit more complicated than that, but it wasn't that hard to follow.

Ah.  I should have pieced that together myself.

Bourbon, who else did you cop as town?

[Deleted]

Jun 23, 2015 14:39:09 GMT -6 @rum said:

Jun 23, 2015 14:32:07 GMT -6 @mead said:

I wouldn't say that.  Bourbon said he trusted Tequlia and another as Town.  I think it was a good assumption that Bourbon was claiming he copped Tequila. Of course, now it's a bit more complicated than that, but it wasn't that hard to follow.

Ah.  I should have pieced that together myself.

Bourbon, who else did you cop as town?

Unlikey, but for all I know, the two of you could be mafia who've learned of two Town members and are looking for the third. You have one of my targets, you have my character, and you have my highly unreliable powers. I'd like to get some info from other players before revealing anything else.

[Deleted]

Okay, well after all that, we are in the last third of the day, and its important to remember this was always dual pressure in addition to Liqueur.

Vote Liqueur

I think that takes us to 6 of 9.

[Deleted]

Jun 23, 2015 14:52:46 GMT -6 @bourbon said:

Jun 23, 2015 14:39:09 GMT -6 @rum said:

Ah.  I should have pieced that together myself.

Bourbon, who else did you cop as town?

Unlikey, but for all I know, the two of you could be mafia who've learned of two Town members and are looking for the third. You have one of my targets, you have my character, and you have my highly unreliable powers. I'd like to get some info from other players before revealing anything else.

If they were mafia, wouldn't they already know who is town and who isn't?
There's three neutrals outed. That leaves maybe 1 left?